New York City 5×10 Bathroom Remodel: A Complete Cost Guide

Renovating a 5×10 bathroom in New York City is one of the smartest investments you can make in your home. At 50 square feet, a full-sized bathroom has some unexpected possibilities. However, your remodeling choices will determine the costs. Here’s everything you need to know before you dive in.

What Does a 5×10 Bathroom Remodel Cost in NYC?

The price tag on a 5×10 bathroom remodel depends on finish level, fixture count, and whether you are keeping the existing layout. For a standard full bathroom without layout changes, here’s where starting costs land:

• Budget remodel: Starting at $18,000
• Mid-grade remodel: Starting at $28,000
• High-end remodel: Starting at $40,500

These figures include all materials, labor, overhead, and a standard contractor margin. No surprise fees hiding in the fine print.

Finish Level: Your Biggest Cost Driver

Your choice of finishes can single-handedly double or triple your remodel budget. This is where most homeowners either save big or splurge wisely.

Budget Finishes

Off-the-shelf vanities, ceramic tile under $5 per square foot, and fixtures from brands like Moen or Delta keep costs lean without sacrificing function.

Mid-Grade Finishes

Brands like Kohler, Hansgrohe, and American Standard hit the sweet spot with quality materials that elevate the look without a luxury price tag. Tile from retailers like TileBar works beautifully here.

High-End and Luxury Finishes

Custom vanities, statement tile from Ann Sacks or Clé Tile, and fixtures from Brizo or Kallista transform your 5×10 into a genuine spa retreat. Fixtures alone at this level can run $15,000 or more.

Rip-and-Replace vs. Gut Renovation

The scope of your 5×10 bathroom remodel dramatically affects your final bill. Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Rip-and-replace: All fixtures and finishes are swapped out while the existing layout stays intact. This is the most cost-effective and most popular approach for standard 5×10 bathrooms.
• Gut renovation: Walls come down, plumbing gets rerouted, and the layout changes completely. Expect to add 15–25% on top of your base remodel cost.
• Permits and architecture: A gut renovation in NYC typically requires DOB permits and may need a licensed architect or designer, adding 10–20% of the construction budget in design fees.

If your plumbing is in good shape and your layout works, a rip-and-replace is usually the smartest move for a 5×10.

Hidden Costs to Budget For

Even the most carefully planned 5×10 bathroom remodel can uncover surprises once the walls open up. Smart homeowners plan ahead:

• Demolition costs in NYC typically start at $39 per square foot
• Labor accounts for roughly 25–35% of the total project cost
• Tiling runs between $26 and $82 per square foot installed
• Contingency fund: Set aside 10–15% for a rip-and-replace, and 15–20% for a gut renovation

Old plumbing, outdated electrical, and water damage are the most common culprits behind budget overruns.

Your Perfect 5×10 Is Waiting

A well-executed 5×10 bathroom remodel adds real value to your NYC home and real joy to your daily routine. Whether you are keeping it budget-friendly or going full luxury, knowing your numbers upfront puts you in control. Work with a contractor who knows New York’s unique building landscape, and you’ll be thrilled with the results.

Contact Zicklin Contracting at zicklincontracting.com today, and let’s bring your 5×10 bathroom vision to life.