Your bathroom deserves better than those cracked tiles and outdated fixtures. But when it comes to renovation, the bath fitter cost might surprise you—and not always in a good way. Before you commit to an acrylic overlay, let’s dive into whether this quick-fix solution truly delivers bang for your buck or if you’re better off exploring alternatives.
What Exactly Are You Paying For?
Bath Fitter specializes in acrylic liners that fit over your existing tub and wall surrounds. Sounds convenient, right? The average bath fitter cost ranges from $3,000 to $10,000, depending on your bathroom size and customization needs. That’s significantly higher than a standard tub replacement, which typically runs $1,400 to $5,500 with professional installation.
Here’s the breakdown:
- Acrylic overlay installation: $3,000-$10,000
- Standard tub replacement: $1,400-$5,500
- Full bathroom remodel: $6,000-$15,000+
That means a Bath Fitter system often costs as much—or more—than a full renovation, even though it doesn’t replace your existing tub or address underlying issues.
The Hidden Catch Behind Quick Installation
Sure, Bath Fitter promises installation in just one or two days. But there’s a catch lurking beneath that shiny acrylic surface.
Covering Problems Instead of Solving Them
Your existing tub might harbor hidden issues—water damage, mold, or structural problems. Bath Fitter simply covers these issues rather than addressing them. At Zicklin, we believe in doing things right the first time, which means identifying and fixing underlying problems before they become costly disasters.
When Does Bath Fitter Actually Make Sense?
Let’s be fair—there are scenarios where Bath Fitter shines:
- You’re preparing to sell and need cosmetic improvements fast
- Your existing tub structure is completely sound
- You want to avoid the mess of demolition temporarily
However, if you’re planning to stay in your home long-term, investing in a proper renovation delivers better value and longevity.
The Zicklin Contracting Advantage
Why settle for a band-aid solution when you can have a complete transformation? Our comprehensive bathroom renovations address every detail, from plumbing updates to stunning tile work. While the bath fitter cost might seem attractive initially, our complete remodels often provide:
Superior customization: Choose any material, color, or design—not just what fits the Bath Fitter catalog
Long-term durability: Quality materials that last decades, not just a surface-level cover-up
Increased home value: Real renovations boost resale value significantly more than overlay systems
